SUMMARY: Hereditary factors play an important role in the risk of developing several cancers. Therefore, identification of a germline predisposition can have important implications for treatment decision making, risk-reducing interventions, cancer screening for early diagnosis, germline testing and targeted surveillance of unaffected relatives. Previously published studies have been biased by estimating the prevalence of germline cancer susceptibility in patients with breast, prostate, and colorectal cancer from registry populations, genetic testing companies, and high-risk cancer clinics.
With the widespread adoption of Next Generation Sequencing (NGS), multiple genes can be tested simultaneously (MultiGene Panel Testing-MGPT), rather than sequential single-gene testing, making MultiGene Panel Testing cheaper, faster and more efficient. Further, single-test multigene multiplexing strategy analyzes numerous cancer susceptibility genes and frequently detects highly penetrant, clinically actionable Pathogenic Germline Variants (PGV) in individuals whose clinical histories fail to fulfill syndrome-specific testing criteria. This is clinically relevant, as it has become increasingly complex to determine which individuals warrant germline testing. Several risk assessment models have been developed to provide probability of an individual carrying a germline mutation. These models provide syndrome-specific risk assessment for Lynch Syndrome, Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer syndrome (HBOC)), etc.
The Genomics and Population Health Action Collaborative was formed in 2015 with the goal of identifying challenges and potential best practices for the widespread integration of evidence-based genomics applications in population health programs. They endorsed 11 genes associated with the three CDC Tier 1 inherited Autosomal Dominant cancer predisposition conditions – Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer syndrome, Lynch syndrome, and Familial Hypercholesterolemia, as being a reasonable starting point for primary genomic screening in the general population.
Tapestry study is collaboration between Mayo Clinic and Helix, a population genomics company. The Tapestry trial included 44,306 patients who received treatment across Mayo Clinic sites in Minnesota, Arizona and Florida. Researchers gathered and evaluated saliva samples for pathogenic mutations in BRCA1 and BRCA2 (denoting Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer), as well as MLH1, MSH2, MSH6, PMS2 and EPCAM (denoting Lynch syndrome). The mean age was 55 years, 63% were women and 90% were Caucasian. The aim of this study was to evaluate whether screening in a multisite tertiary medical center using Whole Exome Sequencing (WES) could efficiently identify carriers of two conditions, Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancers and Lynch syndrome, and determine the frequency of incremental carriers identified outside of traditional clinical practice guidelines.
The researchers identified 550 carriers of pathogenic mutations, including 387 individuals with Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer syndrome (HBOC) and 163 with Lynch syndrome. Of these individuals with pathogenic mutations, 52.1% had no knowledge prior to this study that they carried cancer predisposition genes, and 39.2% of CARRIERS did not meet NCCN criteria for genetic testing, including 56.2% of those with Lynch syndrome and 32% of those with HBOC. Among the patients who were NEWLY DIAGNOSED with Lynch syndrome and HBOC syndrome during this study, 60% were ineligible for genetic testing per the current guidelines. They included 78% of those with Lynch syndrome and 51% of those with HBOC syndrome. Some of the reasons for not meeting NCCN criteria included having no personal history of cancer (63.3%), an insufficient number of relatives who had cancer (60.5%) and a cancer type or types not related to a genetic syndrome (58.6%). Among those who met NCCN guidelines for testing, 34.2% reported not knowing their diagnosis prior to the study. The researchers also noted that patients with HBOC or Lynch syndrome from racial and ethnic minority groups were significantly more likely than white patients to not meet NCCN screening criteria (49% versus 32%, respectively).
It was concluded that genomic screening in the broad general population for CDC Tier 1 genetic conditions has the potential to identify 50% of at-risk carriers who are otherwise not detected in current medical practice. Early diagnosis and intervention could have a positive impact on public health, and a systemic bias in the current guidelines could potentially be overcome by universal genetic testing. The authors added that the limitation of this study is that the patient population in this study may not reflect the demographics of the general population.
Exome sequencing identifies individuals with cancer predisposition syndromes missed by current screening guidelines (AACR press release). Available at: www.aacr.org/about-the-aacr/newsroom/news-releases/exome-sequencing-identifies-individuals-with-cancer-predisposition-syndromes-missed-by-current-screening-guidelines/. Published April 18, 2023.